← All episodes

Episode 6 · My Child Needs Special Education: Now What?

Does it travel?

The note came home. Now what? A practicing school psychologist shows parents how to sort Normal, Not Yet, and Needs Help, and the one question that tells a growing pain from something that needs a closer look: does it TRAVEL?

6:33 · Download MP3

In this episode

  • Why the range of typical development is wider than most parents are ever shown
  • Three bins instead of two: Normal, Not Yet, and Needs Help
  • The TRAVEL test: Time, Rooms, Adults, Volume, Effort, Life
  • Two gates, route versus destination, and a key, not a name: three ideas to carry into any school meeting
  • A one-page sorting exercise for this week, plus where to turn next

Transcript

The note came home. You've read it four times, standing in the kitchen with your coat still on. Now what?

I'm Dr. Philip Hickman, and this is The Human Advantage.

I'm a practicing school psychologist. Most weeks, I'm the person at the table explaining what a child's evaluation does and doesn't say. So before we start, one honest line. This episode is general information. It can't tell you what's going on with your child. Your school team, your pediatrician, and the licensed professionals who know your child can. What I can give you is a way to think, so you walk into those conversations steady.

Let's start with the thing nobody shows parents. The range of normal is wider than you were told.

Take sitting still. Most children can sit through a structured fifteen-minute group lesson somewhere between about four and a half and seven years old. That's a two-and-a-half-year range, for a skill kindergarten teachers are asked to rate in the first quarter of the year. So picture a five-year-old boy who's the youngest in his class by almost a year. In September, he can't sit through carpet time. He may look behind. He may also be right inside the curve.

Here's why parents panic. We've been handed two bins. Fine and not fine. Two bins force a decision before there's enough information, and they force it toward fear. So I give families three bins.

Normal. The behavior falls inside the typical range for a child that age. It might be at the late edge. But it's inside the curve.

Not Yet. The skill isn't there, but the reason may be timing, not wiring. The teaching is good. The child is paying attention. The brain just hasn't finished building the system the skill runs on. The job here is to keep teaching, calmly, in small daily doses. I call that Teach It Anyway, so that when the hardware arrives, the software's already installed.

Needs Help. The difference is real, it persists, it shows up everywhere the child goes, and it doesn't respond to good teaching the way Not Yet does. And Needs Help isn't a tragedy. In my experience, the children who struggle most over time aren't the ones with disabilities. They're the ones whose needs were called Not Yet for three years by adults who were afraid of the label.

So how do you tell Not Yet from Needs Help? You ask one question. Does it travel?

A growing pain stays home. A disability travels. It goes with the child to school, to church, to the ball field, to Grandma's house. I turned that idea into a six-letter question I ask about every child who's referred to me. TRAVEL.

T is Time. Has this lasted six months or more, across a change of grade or teacher?

R is Rooms. Does it show up in more than one setting?

A is Adults. Do adults who don't talk to each other notice it on their own? A teacher, a coach, a grandparent, a pediatrician?

V is Volume. Is it well beyond what you'd see in children the same age and sex, not just the kids in this one classroom?

E is Effort. Was good teaching or parenting tried, and did the gap stay or widen? Effort isn't about whether the child tried. It's about whether good teaching was tried.

L is Life. Does it get in the way of learning, friendships, or daily living?

You don't need all six to be worried. You need to know how many you have. One or two letters, often Rooms and Volume in a single classroom, usually means watch and keep teaching. Four or more means it's time to ask for a full evaluation, in writing, no matter what anyone tells you about waiting.

Because here's the hard part. Wait and see is never the whole answer. In reading, gaps compound. A child who reads a little more in first grade practices more, gets better, and by fourth grade a small gap can become a canyon. Researchers call it the Matthew effect. Reading help works best from kindergarten through second grade. It still works later. It just takes far more hours to get the same result. So know the range, sort the bins, and act the moment the letters add up.

When you do get to an evaluation, carry three more ideas with you.

First, two gates, not one. A diagnosis is a doctor's answer to, what does my child have? Eligibility is the school team's answer to, does my child need specially designed instruction because of it? A child can have a diagnosis and not be eligible. A child can be eligible with no diagnosis at all. A doctor's letter, by itself, opens neither gate.

Second, route versus destination. This is how I explain what parents run into with an I E P or a five-oh-four plan. An accommodation changes the route. Your child is headed to the same place as everyone else, the same standard, the same test, and the accommodation changes how she gets there. Extra time. A quiet room. A keyboard instead of a pencil. A modification changes the destination. She's expected to learn something different, or less. Sometimes that's exactly right. But it's the most consequential thing a parent can agree to without noticing, because a destination moved in fourth grade is still moved in ninth. So ask, every time, is this changing the route or the destination?

And third, a key, not a name. A category is a key. It opens the door to instruction, services, and protections, and when your child needs what's behind that door, the key is worth fighting for. But a key doesn't describe the person holding it. It doesn't tell anyone your child is funny, or gentle, or wins every argument about basketball.

Here's your one thing for this week. Take the one concern that's been keeping you up. Write the six letters down the side of a page. Time. Rooms. Adults. Volume. Effort. Life. Go through them honestly and count. If you land on one or two, start Teach It Anyway tonight. Four minutes, not twenty, on the skill that worries you most, and a mark on a sticky note on the refrigerator every day you do it. If you land on four or more, write a short letter to your school this week asking for a comprehensive evaluation, and bring the same page to your child's pediatrician. Either way, you're not guessing anymore.

If this helped, the book is My Child Needs Special Education: Now What? I'll see you next time.