Special education · Parenting
Growing pain or something more? Ask whether it travels
Before you ask for a test, ask six questions. The TRAVEL check helps parents sort what to watch from what to raise with the school team and pediatrician.
Dr. Philip Hickman · 6 min read
The note from school is usually kind. “Having some difficulty during carpet time.” “Would love to connect.” Most parents still read it the same way: something is wrong with my child. By morning, after a night of searching, they’ve decided what to have their child tested for.
I’ve sat across the table from a lot of those parents. Before anyone talks about testing, I ask one question, and I want you to have it too: does it travel?
Three bins, not two
Most of us sort worries into two bins: fine, or a problem. In My Child Needs Special Education: Now What? I use three.
- Normal. The behavior may be annoying, and it may come up at conferences, but it sits inside the range of typical development. That range is much wider than school makes it look.
- Not Yet. The skill isn’t there, but the reason is timing. The teaching is right, the child is paying attention, and the brain simply hasn’t finished building what the skill runs on. The job is to keep teaching in small daily doses.
- Needs Help. The difference is real, it persists, it shows up wherever the child goes, and it doesn’t respond to good teaching and steady parenting the way Not Yet does. This is when you bring in the people trained to look closer.
The whole job is the sorting, and the sorting question fits on a card.
The TRAVEL test
A growing pain tends to stay home. It belongs to one room, one adult, one season, and it fades as the child gets older. A concern that needs help tends to travel: to school, to practice, to Grandma’s house, across a change of grade. Here are the six letters, with the question to ask for each.
- T: Time. Has this lasted six months or more, and across a change of grade or teacher?
- R: Rooms. Does it show up in more than one setting?
- A: Adults. Do adults who don’t talk to each other see it on their own?
- V: Volume. Is it well beyond same-age, same-sex peers?
- E: Effort. Has good instruction or consistent parenting been tried, and did the gap stay or widen?
- L: Life. Does it get in the way of learning, friendships, or daily living?
You don’t need all six to be concerned. You need to know how many you have.
Reading the count
One or two letters, most often Rooms and Volume in a single classroom, usually means watch and teach. If the school offers extra help, say yes, ask for the plan and the progress graph in writing, and set a review date.
Four or more letters means it’s time to ask the school, in writing, for a comprehensive evaluation, and to talk with your pediatrician. Don’t let anyone talk you into simply waiting.
Three letters sits in between. If a round of extra help is already behind you and the line is still flat, treat it like four. If nothing has been tried yet, ask for a written plan with a clock on it. Extra help and an evaluation can also run at the same time.
One caution. The count doesn’t diagnose anything, and neither does a blog post. It tells you whether to keep teaching and watching, or whether it’s time for your school team and your child’s doctor to take a careful look.
Two quick examples
Picture a kindergartner, the youngest in his class by almost a year, three weeks into school. He can’t sit through a fifteen-minute carpet lesson, and his pencil grip is awkward. Time: three weeks. Rooms: his preschool and Sunday school teachers have no concerns, and he builds with blocks at home for forty minutes. Adults: one. Volume: next to the other summer birthdays, he looks ordinary. Effort: nothing has been tried yet. Life: he’s learning, and he has friends. Zero letters. Keep teaching, and look again in January.
Now picture a second grader whose first-grade teacher and current teacher raised the same reading concern, whose coach and grandmother have noticed she avoids reading anything aloud, and whose reading hasn’t moved after twelve weeks of small-group help. Time, Adults, Effort, Life, and probably Rooms. That’s not a child to wait on.
Why “wait and see” is never the whole answer
Not Yet is the most common thing I see. But waiting is not neutral. In reading, small early gaps tend to grow, a pattern researchers call the Matthew effect: the child who reads a little better reads more, improves faster, and the gap widens. That’s why the test has an E in it. Effort doesn’t mean “has the child tried.” It means “has good teaching been tried, and did it work.”
It’s also why I always ask what a behavior is sitting on top of. Early in my career I evaluated a first grader whose teacher was sure the problem was attention. The rating scales agreed. Then I added a measure of early sound skills, and he couldn’t tell me the first sound in his own name. The scales described the behavior accurately. They missed the reason.
What acting looks like, in order
If the letters add up, acting means three concrete steps.
- Check the body first. Have hearing and vision checked this week by a professional, not by a school screening alone.
- Write a dated letter to the principal requesting a comprehensive evaluation, and keep a copy. A spoken request has no date. For a child under three, call your state’s early intervention program instead.
- Keep teaching while you wait. Four minutes a day on the skill that worries you most.
Talk with your pediatrician along the way. The doctor and the school each see things the other doesn’t.
One sign never waits for a count. If your child talks about hurting herself or not wanting to be alive, in any tone, call her doctor today. In the United States, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. If there is immediate danger, call 911.
Start the folder tonight
The most useful thing a worried parent can have is a dated record. Get a binder or a big envelope and write your child’s name and today’s date on it. Once a week, same day, same kind of material, do one one-minute check of the skill that worries you: words read correctly from a page at her level, letter sounds, or math facts. Write the number, the date, and what you used on an index card, and drop it in.
Six numbers make a line. In six weeks you may know more about whether she’s moving than anyone else in her life.
Questions to ask the teacher
- “Where does my child fall compared with children the same age and sex, not just this class?”
- “What have you tried so far, for how long, and what changed?”
- “Do you see this in every setting, or mostly during one kind of activity?”
- “Did last year’s teacher or preschool mention anything like this?”
- “What would you expect to see by January if this is just maturity, and what would make you more concerned?”
What to do this week
- Write down the one concern that worries you most.
- Run the six letters on it and write the date beside your count.
- Ask one other adult who sees your child, a coach or a grandparent, what they notice, without sharing your worry first.
- Start the folder and do your first one-minute check.
- If you counted four or more, write the letter and call the pediatrician.
The free Does It Travel? check takes you through the six letters one at a time. It’s for reflection, not a clinical measure, so bring what you find to your school team and your child’s doctor.
From the bookMy Child Needs Special Education: Now What?What Is Normal, What Is Not Yet, and What Truly Needs Help